double issue marks JASHM's thirtieth year of
publication. In celebration, we devote this issue to honoring the life and work
of JASHM's founder and senior editor, Dr.
Drid Williams. SinceJASHM's inception at New
York University in 1979 (see History of JASHM),
Dr. Williams has been an unwavering force: dedicated to nurturing and
publishing the work of students and colleagues, making historically important
primary materials easily accessible, and embracing a wide range of
interdisciplinary contributions. Thanks to Dr. Williams's conviction about the
long-term importance of a journal specific to this subfield, current and future
generations possess a thirty-year record of sound research and scholarship in
the anthropology of human movement.
In
celebration of Dr. Williams's eightieth year, an international conference and
performance Body, Movement and Dance in Global Perspective took place in
Kowloon, Hong Kong, July 24–26th, 2008. This double issue is comprised of
a selection of papers from that conference, together with illustrations and
other supporting materials.
The
idea for the 2008 conference was conceived when a number of colleagues suggested
it would be productive and timely to convene a state-of-the-art international
conference on the anthropology of the dance and human movement. The idea began
to take on a reality after a prescient suggestion by my research colleague and
friend, choreographer and artistic director Robert Wood. Instead of organizing
the event in familiar territory and asking Dr. Williams to travel all the way
to the U.S. from China (where she was teaching at the time), he proposed, "Why
don't we go to China?" The rest, as they say . . . is history.
Figure 1.2. The conference program, designed by Ada Lee, Brenda Farnell, and Robert Wood.
Organizing
the events turned out to be a journey all its own, as the occasion became an
ambitious joint endeavor coorganized and cosponsored by no less than four institutions. Planning was soon underway, thanks to Paul Hockings's openness to
the very idea of a conference plus live performance and a joint commitment from
United International College (UIC), Zhuhai, China, and the Department of
Anthropology, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC) to cosponsor
the event.
Wood's
Movement Arts organization, Robert Wood Dance-New York Inc. (RWDNY),
also made a generous commitment to a four-week choreographic residency in order
to develop an on-site choreographic work, The Pearl Sea, a movement
exploration that would premiere as a live performance in conjunction with the
conference. The Pearl Sea would embrace Chinese dance artists and
musicians in collaboration with RWDNY artists from the U.S. and France.
Eventually,
as a result of changed circumstances, UIUC, UIC, and RWDNY were joined
by the Department of Sociology, Hong Kong Baptist University (HKBU). We are
most grateful to each of these institutions and organizations and to persons
too many to mention here, for the incredible amount of time, money, energy, and
goodwill that made possible the joint conference and performance.
Figure 1.3. The logos of the four sponsoring institutions, from left to right: Hong Kong Baptist University; University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; United International College, Zhuhai; and Robert Wood Dance-New York Inc.
We
especially wish to extend our heartfelt thanks for the energy, intelligence,
and commitment shown by Professors Odalia Wong and Kwok-Bun (KB) Chan at the
Department of Sociology at Hong Kong Baptist University, both of whom fully
embraced and supported the organization of the conference and The Pearl Sea performance at very short notice when circumstances necessitated a change of
venue from the UIC Zhuhai campus in mainland China to HKBU in Hong Kong.
The
circumstances that necessitated the transfer to Hong Kong are themselves of
anthropological interest. In the context of the 2008 Olympic Games in Beijing
that summer, the Chinese national government had became increasingly nervous of
the possibility of outside protestors disrupting the games and increasingly
suspicious of any foreign presence in China except the Olympics. Possibly as a
result, the Guangdong regional authorities consistently failed to provide
conference coorganizers at UIC Zhuhai with the necessary permission to hold the
conference. When, in May, the Chinese government suddenly canceled the large
16th World Congress of the International Union of Anthropological and
Ethnological Sciences in Kunming and anthropological colleagues
began to report that entry visas for China were being refused, it became clear
that we could not proceed as planned to host the conference on the UIC campus
in mainland China. We sincerely thank Paul Hockings for his facilitation
of the transfer to HKBU and his extraordinary ongoing support, as we completely
shifted gears at the last moment!
The
elegant, poetic Preface to the Conference Program provides a fitting
entrée to the papers in this issue. It is written by Professor KB Chan,
distinguished chair professor of Sociology and former director of the David C.
Lam Institute for East-West Studies at Hong Kong Baptist University. Professor
Chan's generosity and hospitality throughout our stay was nothing short of
stupendous. We are most grateful for the many extraordinary kindnesses and efforts
he made on our behalf. Robert Wood and I deeply appreciated his imaginative and
personal response to our scholarly and artistic goals, as well as our daily
presence during four weeks of very intense activity.
The
exquisite Chinese calligraphic art that appears on the Contents page of this issue, the
significance of which is discussed in Prof. Chan's preface, was the generous
gift of Mr. Francis Lee. We remain honored and delighted that his distinctive
artistry graced not only the conference and performance programs and posters
but also the The Pearl Sea stage set.
Figure 1.19. Calligraphic art derived from the Chinese character for "dance" was created especially for the occasion and generously donated by Mr. Francis Lee.
Following
the preface is a biographical statement about Dr. Williams that also appeared
in the conference program. It is here illustrated with historical photographs
and a slideshow of images from the conference. An illustrated transcript of Dr.
Williams's thoughtful address given on the occasion of the conference banquet
follows.
The
conference papers begin with keynote addresses1 contributed by two distinguished scholars well known to JASHM readers. David Best's lucid paper "The Social Mind," which explores ongoing
pitfalls of Cartesian dualistic thinking about body/mind, generated interesting
discussion throughout the conference that brought Western and Asian thinking
into conversation.
Charles
Varela's "The Pioneering Moment of Drid Williams" masterfully situates
semasiology within the history of major problems in social theory, as well as
the history of science and philosophy. His in-depth examination of the twin
problems of freedom versus determinism and social structure versus agency
relates to the task of developing theories of embodiment and dynamic embodiment
(the moving person) that are scientifically plausible for the social sciences.
He makes a convincing case that shows precisely how semasiology provides us
with such a theory.
Holly
Fairbank's contributions to the conference were multiple. Not only did she
present an insightful paper that reflected on her earlier research on minority
dances in China, but she also performed an intriguing and beautifully crafted
solo dance, part of an ongoing conversation with Chinese aesthetics and her
relationship to its history via her parents' pioneering work in the field of
Chinese Studies. Holly's fine contributions helped us fulfill our goal of
combining both intellectual and performance elements within the same event.
Holly's
paper is the first of four that report on a variety of research on the dance in
East Asia. Chifang Chou's paper explores the significance and multiple meanings
of one particular recurring action sign of "holding hands" within indigenous
Taiwanese cultures. Minako Nakamura and colleagues, Yukido Kado and Kohji
Shibano, share their initial research efforts toward developing a digital
archive that will document the work of a leading Japanese ballet choreographer,
Ms. Tatsua Sata. Shu-Chi Piao describes her recent dance-education research
with parents and children at the Cloud Gate School in Taipei, Taiwan.
The
final contribution takes the anthropology of human movement into the realm of
disability studies in a challenging paper by Beth Marks and Jasmina Sisirak who
ask us to rethink our concepts of "health" and "movement" from the perspective
of persons with disabilities. I believe that using our anthropological
imaginations to include persons with disabilities expands our thinking in
important ways, not least in the sense of being confronted with ranges of
movement possibility that are extraordinary in ways not previously considered
in our field to date. I am most grateful to Beth for coming to the conference
and contributing this thought-provoking paper and to the University of Illinois
at Chicago for sponsoring her most active participation.
We
found ourselves competing with several other conferences that summer, so
attendance at the conference was relatively small. However, many participants
expressed their great pleasure in the intimacy this afforded and the
possibilities it provided for in-depth discussions that carried over from one
session to another or became shared conversations over lunch and dinner. This
reminds me that I cannot forget to mention the magnificent food we enjoyed
throughout our stay--from the excellent and varied daily Dim Sum lunches to the
delicious, seemingly never-ending dishes of the conference banquet, both provided
by the Renfrew Restaurant on the HKBU campus, and, finally, to the elegant
lunch generously sponsored by HKBU Sociology Alumni Association.
I
want to close by emphasizing how central the presence of RWDNY and The
Pearl Sea performance was to the overall event, even though this fact
cannot be adequately presented in a journal format. There was an equal
theoretical partnership between the conference papers on the centrality of body
movement to our human-being-in-the-world and the studio work and stage
presentation of that very theme.
Both
aspects of the event complemented each other because Robert Wood's distinct
approach to the creative process seeks to reveal to the viewer attributes of
the dancer's personal and cultural being, as this is constructed through and
revealed in his or her movement. Persons are, for Wood, fundamentally moving
beings, and his work involves creating environments that allow the
mover/dancer to discover this for her-/himself, encouraging and anticipating a
state of being that draws deeply on the dancer's unique personal, cultural, and
ancestral dispositions, histories, and experiences. The dancer as a person is the primary focus of attention in his work and source of movement material
and knowledge, thus complementing the anthropological focus on dynamically
embodied personhood in our academic presentations. Wood's work in the studio
with the selected dance artists from Hong Kong and members of RWDNY,
which resulted in "17 sections of time and space arranged specially for this
performance and location" thus deeply complemented and enriched the theoretical
thrust of the conference.
Figure 1.51. RWDNY Inc., choreographer, dance artists, and friends pose for the camera at The
Pearl Sea postperformance reception. From left to right: Mrs. Francis Lee,
Mr. Francis Lee, Brenda Farnell, Robert N. Wood, Ling-Fen Chien, Benjamin
Mielke, KB Chan, Monica Graves, Emilie Volck, and Vivien Chan.
Brenda Farnell
Acknowledgments
In addition to
the four major sponsors of the event, we wish to recognize the following
departments and individuals with sincere thanks for their support:
Hong Kong
Hong Kong Baptist University
Office of the President and Vice
President
Faculty of the Social Sciences
School of Continuing Education
Academic Community Hall
Department of Music
Department of Cinema and Television
Office of United International
College
Estate office
Financial office
Student Housing Section, Office of
Student Affairs
Sociology Society
China Studies Society
Hong Kong Baptist University
Sociology Alumni Association
Mr. Francis Lee
Australian International School,
Hong Kong
Mainland China
Institute for Cross Cultural
Research, United International College
United States of America
University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign
Office of the Chancellor
College of Fine Arts
International Studies
East Asian Languages and Cultures
Program
Center for East Asian and Pacific
Studies
Department of Dance
Department of Theater
Illinois Program for Research in
the Humanities
University of Illinois at Chicago
International Studies
Savannah College of Art and Design, Georgia
Office of the President
Department of Film and Digital
Media, Savannah College of Art and Design
Department of Performing Arts,
Savannah College of Art and Design
On-site Conference Organizing
Committee (in alphabetical order)
KB Chan, Vivien Wai-wan Chan,
Maurice Kwok-to Choi, Brenda Farnell, Paul Hockings, Ada Man-ching Lee, Bee Man-wai
Lee, Anna Siu-po Lo, Karen Wing-yi Lo, Christie Mei-kuen Tang, Odalia Min–hueng Wong, Cindy Shuet-ying Wong, Robert Wood
The Pearl Sea Project
Direction and Choreography: Robert
N. Wood
Sound Design and Composition:
Robert Miller
Costumes: Coco Chien
Lighting Improvisation: David Tang
Dance Artists: Ling-Fen Chien,
Benjamin Mielke, Emilie Volck, Monica Graves, Hofan Chau, Eric Huynh, Connie
Lau, Cherry Leung, Man Liu, Katie Ma, Vicky Man, Malvina Tam, Emma Wong, Anson
Tse
Note:
1 Unfortunately, the third keynote address, by Rachel Fensham, was unable to be
published here, but see abstracts at the end of the issue.
Content in Journal for the Anthropological Study of Human Movement (ISSN 1940-7610) is intended for personal,
noncommercial use only. You may not reproduce, publish, distribute, transmit,
participate in the transfer or sale of, modify, create derivative works
from, display, or in any way exploit the Journal for the Anthropological Study of Human Movement
database in whole or in part without the written permission of the copyright
holder.